I was struck by the the focus of the distinction between malice that is intentional and incontinence. To be honest I didn’t know what incontinence meant but the Merriam-Webster definition states it as the, “inability of the body to control the functions of urination or defecation.” This definition very well explains the, “horrible excess of stench” explained at the very beginning of the canto (Inferno 11, 3). It seems a little odd that this punishment of essentially being immersed in ones own waste because of the lack of control would be given to those who have committed fraud, which to my understanding is a choice. I believe Dante did this on purpose. By doing this he created an ironic parallel between the sin and the punishment of these damned souls. This ties in with the fact that fraud is an even greater sin than violence in God’s eyes (Inferno 11, 25). Committing fraud means the manipulation of another’s blind trust that stems from love which, “…seems to cut solely into the bond of love that Nature makes”( Inferno 11, 55). Nature in this case signifies God and we can notice this in the intentional capitalization of “N”. And this all comes full circle to validate why Dante is worthy of going on this journey in the first place by the line, “…your art follows Nature as much as it can, as a disciple follows the master; so that your art is almost God’s grandchild”(Inferno 11, 103). Dante’s romantic poetry is almost like a sign of devotion to God in its own right.


