Tag Archives: social status

Pride and Position

Dante watches as the prideful purge themselves, Title: Proud Penitents (Oderisi da Gubbio), Illustration by Gustave Doré, Source: Danteworlds (UTexas) (Galleries of Purgatory (Terrace of Pride))

As Dante and Virgil continue to voyage through purgatory they find themselves on the first terrace in canto 10. Each of the seven terraces symbolize the seven capital vices, of which the travelers encounter the prideful souls. Dante, as the author, purposefully creates parallels between cantos of the same number in purgatory and inferno. As an example, upon entrance in both the sixth circle of heresy and the terrace of pride, not a single soul is visible in sight. The reason for this could possibly be that the arrogance with which the souls carry themselves push them to believe that any visitors that come their way aren’t worthy of seeing who they are immediately nor are the visitors worthy of knowing who they are. While this may not be true for all the souls of the sixth circle, the behavior of the souls that Dante does get to meet indicate otherwise. As for purgatory, the reason for this has to do with the contrapasso of the punishments of the prideful. Each of the souls are forced to look at the ground because of the tremendously heavy stones weighing them down on their spines. This is an opposition to the overly-confident attitudes that the souls have in their living days where their attitudes kept their heads up high during every encounter. The punishment allows them to understand the negative traits they possess and how one cannot spend eternity as someone who treats others as though they are below them. The simultaneous pounding of their chests reflects the process of the purging of the souls into better versions of who they used to be giving them an element of sincerity that lacks in the souls of inferno.

Meanwhile, the sinners of canto 10 in inferno have mainly committed heresy but one character, known as Farinata, shows evidence of pride and arrogance. Dante narrates, “I had already fixed my eyes in his; and he was/ rising up with his breast and forehead as if he had/ Hell in great disdain,” (34-37, 173, Inferno). The focus on his breast and forehead symbolize the importance of courage. Farinata keeps his head held high, which forces Dante to look up to him while they’re conversing as he stands at the base of Farinata’s tomb. This, consequently, creates a hierarchy between the two characters putting Farinata above Dante. As Farinata rises from his tomb in a prideful and arrogant manner, he maintains a calm and collected demeanor despite the circumstances he finds himself in. His pride is further emphasized when Dante proclaims, “…as if he had Hell in great disdain. (34-35, 157, Inferno). The superior tone, in sharp contrast to the souls of purgatory, implies an attitude of superiority that lacks in the atmosphere, itself, of purgatory. Farinata acts as though he is above the afflictions of Hell and cannot be bothered to concern himself with the sufferings that surround him. Furthermore, his bearing implies a concern with social status which is emphasized when he asks Dante if he comes from the opposing political faction of Guelphs. Such attitudes aren’t present either at Dante’s first encounter with the prideful, despite their vices, because if they behave in such a manner, which counters the will of God and his reasoning for placing the souls in either inferno, purgatory or paradise, then the purging souls would not be where they are now in the first place.

The social statuses, however, that Farinata preoccupies himself with are understandable because, the deeper one delves into inferno, the rougher, harsher and more terrifying the souls’ punishments become. Perhaps, he is attempting to prove to Dante that although he is in the sixth circle of Hell, he is worth much more than what God deems him to be, who consequently places him in this petrifying circle. When it comes to purgatory, the higher one climbs the levels of purgatory, the closer they come to the entrance of paradise and all the goodness and light it contains. This signifies that even though the prideful souls are in the first terrace and as a result, aren’t as close to paradise as the rest of the souls, their purging is considered worth the journey. Their social statuses, unlike the souls of inferno, are temporary and are subject to transforming into a brighter and more peaceful eternity as opposed to the devastating and never ending torments of inferno.